Sunday, September 8, 2013

Gap Analysis: Criminal Law

The Guardian published a story this morning entitled "The wealthy 'make mistakes', the poor go to jail." Its the story about a former Wall Street banker who left his Wall Street job to start a photo project documenting the lives of addicts in the Hunts Point section of the Bronx, New York City's poorest neighborhood. While his Wall Street colleagues borrowed and lost others' money and walked away with $300,000 bonuses and government bailouts, a New York City prostitute finds herself going between the streets and jail for having sold her body for $50. The writer explains what he has learned from knowing both the Wall Street banker and the prostitute: "When you're wealthy you make mistakes. When you are poor you go to jail." He further explains:


[...] it is like comparing apples and oranges. That is the point though. We have built two very different societies with two very different sets of values. Takeesha was born into a world with limited opportunities, one where the black market has filled the void. In her world transgressions are resolved via violence, not lawyers. The law as applied to her is simple and stark, with little wiggle room.


Mr one-glove was born into a world with many options. The laws of his land are open for interpretation, and with the right lawyer one can navigate in the vast grey area and never do anything wrong. The rules are often written by and for Mr one-glove and his friends.

There are two points to be made here: First, that there is need for systemic change in how the law treats different classes--whether that be more strictly enforcing the law against professionals, providing more wiggle room for the poor, or meeting the two classes halfway. Second, my guess is that the Wall Street bankers had the help of an army of very expensive attorneys fighting to help him create that interpretive wiggle room in the law, while the prostitute had little to no substantial legal assistance--at most, an overworked public defender.


I still haven't come across any legal startup in the field of criminal law. My guess is that its difficult to find a scaleable solution (since each situation is different), and because it's a scary field for the risk-averse lawyer to enter. After all, the Model Rules for Professional Conduct require that an attorney zealously advocate on behalf of their client. The bar of representation is higher than that for civil cases, making it unlikely that any legal entrepreneur would, for example, offer limited scope or virtual legal services in the field of criminal law. That essentially leaves these folks with the option of hiring expensive legal representation or settling with an overworked, underpaid public defender. (Learn more about the plight of pubic defenders here, here, and here.)


So if you're a legal entrepreneur out there searching for a problem to solve (as if there aren't enough already), this is a field ripe for change.


In the 1800s, Mark Twain joked that “the law is a system that protects everybody who can afford a good lawyer.” Two hundred years later, same story. 

Saturday, September 7, 2013

Legal Tech for the Poor

Reposting this, as it looks to be an interesting event! (Access to Justice point!)
The original posting is here.

Online Resources and Innovative Technologies to Assist the Unrepresented

This workshop will look at online tools that are being used to assist those that have a legal problem and don't have an attorney representing them. They can be in court or in different forums, or they might be dealing with a private party before the case escalates. We will quickly review the building blocks of online self-help: online forms, web chat, and statewide websites and their tools and then focus on new and innovate tools that are coming into place that will be game changers. These include online triage, online self-help forums, SMS Texting for reminders in case, and innovative use of email and websites to serve persons protected by Federal laws in the context of veterans.
Date: Wednesday, September 11, 2013
Time: 1 pm ET / 12 pm CT / 11 am MT/ 10 PT 
Panelists:
Moderator:
  • Claudia Johnson, Pro Bono Net Program Manager LawHelp Interactive
Webinar Details
Register: The training will be held via join.me, so no pre-registration is required. We’ve attached an iCalendar attachment to this email so this event can be easily added to your calendar.
Join the meeting: 
https://join.me/NTAPtraining
Please enter your full name when prompted, followed by your organization information
(i.e. Jillian Theil, Pro Bono Net)
Join the audio conference:
No matter how you join the conference, everyone will be on the same audio call.
By phone:
Join the meeting, click on the phone icon and select "Join by phone." Dial the number and then the conference ID when prompted.
By computer via internet:
Join the meeting, click the phone icon and select 'Join by internet'. Click "Connect."
For more information on how to use the join.me platform, please see this useful resource from LSNTAP.

To see the full schedule of upcoming LSNTAP trainings for the year, please visit http://lsntap.org/trainings. For questions about these trainings, please contact Jillian Theil of Pro Bono Net at jtheil@probono.net or (415) 400-8662, or Brian Rowe of Northwest Justice Project at brianr@nwjustice.org or (206) 395-6094 or through LSNTAP.org chat.

Monday, September 2, 2013

Introductions, or: Bringing to Law a Little More Order



This blog is meant to chronicle the rise of law-related startups and other innovative legal solutions that will afford people more access to justice. But first, a point of honesty-- I really don't know what's out there, and chances are, I'm guessing most people (and even lawyers) don't know either. When I first tried to start Lawcerna in March 2013, I thought I was bloody brilliant for coming up with the idea that law was a field that could or should be disrupted. Fast forward a couple of months, my list of "competitors" made me feel like I was the last person on Earth to have the light bulb go off.

Lawcerna, for now, is belly-up, but I wanted to provide a space for legal entrepreneurs to share their lessons and experiences with each other. After all, the larger we build this community and the more people we encourage to explore legal innovation, the higher the chances are that there will be someone or some people out there who "make it." The more who "make it," the better it is for consumers of legal services, ultimately. Plus, we'll convert those in the legal profession along the way to be more open to better, more efficient way to deliver legal services.

Why does legal innovation matter? A few reasons. The legal industry has priced itself into oblivion, and only in the financial reach of the rich and, sometimes, the destitute (though there is rapidly shrinking funding for non-profit legal services). Due to sky-high tuition rates, lawyers feel financially compelled to work for big law firms to pay their student debt. The ABA continues to sit on its hands when it comes to access to capital, deregulation, and deployment of technology in the legal sector. While every other sector is undergoing disruption, so much of the legal field remains antiquated and old-school. Change is probably also very welcome to lawyers themselves, as we surpass dentists as #1 in suicides. Probably not a great thing thing to brag about...

But there is hope. A few brave souls are trying to change the way law is taught, understood, and practiced. Legal startups and virtual law firms seem to be springing up left and right. Most (like Lawcerna) seem to go under within a year, but many are still chugging along. Their contributions will hopefully create a kinder, gentler practice of law financially accessible to the middle class. It's a commendable effort, so this blog will attempt to capture their stories here. Suggestions are always welcome.