The internet and mobile phones have changed the way people do things. So while consumers are going online to find attorneys, the attorneys are... hiding offline? Read more here.
Wednesday, September 18, 2013
Consumers are Online (Are the Attorneys?)
The internet and mobile phones have changed the way people do things. So while consumers are going online to find attorneys, the attorneys are... hiding offline? Read more here.
Tuesday, September 17, 2013
Lawful.ly: Providing Open-Sourced Annotations for Transactional Documents
Today we feature Chris Murphy, co-founder of Lawful.ly He perfectly articulated what seems to be the catch-22 in the legal startup field. Legal startups are very different from other startup sectors because they really need some basis of legal experience to go off of. At the same time, the old guard with the experience isn't willing, for the most part, to adopt new innovations, while the younger attorneys are open to it, but lack the experience. "The key," Chris says, "is for the young lawyers to correctly pinpoint the problem."
Lawful.ly
has curated documents with annotated explanations that allow you to get the
info you need on those documents. Each annotation is ideally 3-5 sentences (and
no more than one paragraph), and you can link it to something else online which
provides greater detail if you like. We're providing legal information in a
method thats digestable, vetted, and consumer friendly. We think this is
important and even in line with the access to justice movement to make legal information
freely available, because we're all affected by the law. We want to simplify
information and make it available to the public. People shouldn't have to go to
law school or pay $500/hr to educate themselves on the laws that affect them in
their everyday lives.
Tell
me about yourself.
I
went to law school late in life, and was a technical consultant before that.
I'm a transactional attorney by day, and Lawful.ly is a side project for now. When I started
practicing law, I couldn't help but notice how inefficient it was in many ways.
To an extent, I am or was naive to the
legal business, so I'm not steeped so deep in the legal tradition that I'm
afraid to ask "it's making money, why would I change it?" I think that complacency brought on by big
profits is what makes the legal industry so ripe for disruption.
How
did you come up with the idea for Lawful.ly?
At
my company, they didn't pay for general access to Lexis Nexis or Westlaw. Consequently,
I was trying to double check on some specific language free online and I found
that there is a dearth of legal information--or at least good legal
information--on the internet. This didn't make sense to me because anywhere
else, we can just go to the web and figure out what our problems are. You can even use WebMD and similar free sites
for medical information, which is also a regulated area. But with law, its so
hard to find vetted, approved legal information. Bradley had been running into
similar issues, and after a few times talking, we decided we should take a
crack at trying to be the ones who fixed this issue.
I've
talked to other attorneys since then, and looking from the standpoint of a
small law firm or solo attorney, they've told me that they run into this issue
regularly. While they're experts in certain
areas of law, it would feel uncomfortable having to dive into another field
without resorting to, and being charged for, Lexis Nexis or WestLaw, and there
is no other way to obtain this information quickly and easily. We know that for just about every other
industry there are websites where you can look up the collective public wisdom,
but there really is nothing like that for the law.
What's
has been your inspiration?
Bradley
and I were huge fans of Docracy, which markets itself as the GitHub for legal
documents. Docracy has been great at collecting documents, but we found that I
didn't want to go through fifty of them to find a good document. This is significantly more problematic if you
are not an attorney and looking to find a good agreement to use. I thought there must be a better way to
tackle this general problem.
What
problem are you trying to tackle?
In
our market research, we found that everyone looks for legal documents on the
web, including attorneys. 85% of people with legal problems don't talk to an
attorney--only 15% do. I think it must be because of the reputation that the
legal profession has made for itself. Bradley and I spend lots of time undoing
bad agreements. We wanted to find a find a way to keep laypeople from shooting
themselves in the foot with bad contracts from online resources or elsewhere,
and to arm them to speak to an attorney. As well, we wanted to provide an
affordable, modern resource for attorneys who are looking for specific legal
information – something in between the Westlaws and Lexis/Nexis's of the world,
but definitely above Listservs and the like which are still constantly used by
lawyers.
So
what does Lawful.ly
do?
Lawful.ly
has curated documents with annotated explanations that allow you to get the
info you need on those documents. Each annotation is ideally 3-5 sentences (and
no more than one paragraph), and you can link it to something else online which
provides greater detail if you like. We're providing legal information in a
method thats digestable, vetted, and consumer friendly. We think this is
important and even in line with the access to justice movement to make legal information
freely available, because we're all affected by the law. We want to simplify
information and make it available to the public. People shouldn't have to go to
law school or pay $500/hr to educate themselves on the laws that affect them in
their everyday lives.
There
has been a lot of fear-mongering about some sites likes ours, but we want to be
very clear that we're not trying to put lawyers out of business. We are trying
to return attorneys to being counselors. Instead paying attorneys hundreds of
dollars an hour to ask them "what do I do?", we should have clients
that ask us specific, pointed questions instead of coming to us for general
education. In that way, I believe attorneys will be providing more value to
clients.
Any
other similar startups?
A
similar startup, CaseText, has the same idea of annotating legal texts, but
they are doing that to case law. I think
we have very similar ideas, but focused on solving different problems, or at
least problems for different customer segments.
We are supportive of anyone trying to innovate in the legal arena,
however, and have found the legal innovation community to be really supportive
of just about all ideas and companies.
What
was your initial idea?
Lawful.ly
is actually pretty close to the initial concept. I had been looking for an
explanation on the web for some standard legal language that was being used in
a different context, but couldn't find anything helpful without going to one of
the legal research services. It was really hard to find anything on the web on
the topic at all.
Generally,
I think that standard transactional documents ought to be open-sourced. However, even with that, there are big gaps
between having the document (which you easily find online) and understanding
what it means and how it affects you. I found out that its hard to find good
legal information unless you want to pay thousands of dollars. Lawful.ly
is targeting the community of solo/small firms and end users who wouldn't or
couldn't pay that amount anyway.
How
are you planning to monetize?
We
are still investigating a number of routes to monetize. We're committed to the
idea that the access to information must remain free. However, we don't want to
make this a non-profit, at least at this stage, since we feel that brings on
some burdensome administrative duties and limits certain options and opportunities.
What
has been your biggest success?
We've
gotten really good responses from the people we talked to about this. Every
person we talk to, including most attorneys who are younger and more open,
really understand the need. When we talked to people at SXSW they totally got
it! It's nice to have an idea where its clear that there's a gap in the market.
We've also been able to get a number of attorneys on board.
How
old is Lawful.ly?
We
launched our private beta in July 2013. We anticipate moving to a public beta
soon, but we want to add a few more features first.
What
has been your biggest challenge?
Time
and funding. Time because its a side business, and funding because we're
bootstrapping it. There are some revenue models out there that we believe will
absolutely work, but they requires a certain minimum set of users to prove it
out. We need to be able to get to a certain
level of traction on our own funding before we can attract outside investors.
How
are you attracting users?
Bradley
and I have tried to cultivate a select group for our private beta through
social media and our community ties. Bradley is very active in social media,
and we're both connected in the local legal community. We wanted 100-200
attorney users, and not just laymen, because we wanted people to provide real
feedback. We are intentionally trying not to blow it out yet. We're focused on
depth and getting good commentary. We want to be deep, not wide.
Any
advice for the aspiring legal entrepreneur?
Do
your market research. Always ask, don't just go on a hunch. Hunches are a great
way to get started, but you need to verify everything. Ask 50 different people
in each of your target markets. I had tried to do another startup in a
different area, and one of many lessons I learned is to make sure you're really
tackling a pain people have, and not just something you think is a problem.
Otherwise, you may end up building something people don't need.
Anything
else?
If
you start a legal startup, do it in the name of changing the way lawyers
provide service so that it enhances the client's experience. This profession
has to evolve and there is fantastic opportunity out there. Hopefully we'll be
part of it. Change will happen. Successful lawyers in the future will either be
part of that change, or at least embrace the change and get pulled along with
the tide. If not, they may end up being washed out.
Tuesday, September 10, 2013
AttorneyFee: Revolutionizing the Law Firm's Cash Flow
It's always fun to meet someone with similar interests and background as yourself, especially when you're a lawyer NOT practicing law. Then, there are the people that really blow you away and make your jaw drop at their sheer amazingness. Meet Richard Komaiko, co-founder and CEO of AttorneyFee. His CrunchBase profile describes him as a "policy wonk turned technologist turned crusader for access to justice" who writes books during his down time and speaks four languages (Spanish, Hebrew, Mandarin, Shanghainese). Now, I was once a Foreign Affairs Officer for the State Department and my daily bread and butter is in international economic policy, but even I can't top that. Read more below to find how how Richard plans to turn the traditional law firm business model on its head.
Tell me about yourself.
Like you, I spent some time in DC working on U.S.-China relations. During my time on the Hill, I wrote a book entitled "Lawyers in Modern China" which analyzes rule of law and the legal landscape in China. When it got published, I figured I should probably go to law school since I had written a book on the law. While I was in law school, the market fell apart and I knew I had to look for alternatives to the traditional practice of law. I worked on AttorneyFee, which at the time was just a project with a couple of friends, and we kept pivoting until we were viable.
You never wanted to practice law?
I would not be a very good lawyer. I'm not barred. Even for attorney fee, while I initially did a lot of the legal work for the startup myself, I ended up outsourcing a lot of the legal work. I learned a lot from that experience that I'm not good at practicing law.
Do you think you need to have had practiced law to start a legal startup?
Nope.
How did AttorneyFee start?
Our first idea for AttorneyFee was a platform where potential clients could describe a problem, post it, and find a lawyer. There was no barrier to entry. We realized that it would be a failing model because it inevitably led to a race to the bottom. We did find out, though, that price discovery was a component that people liked. Clients don't want to waste their time telling a lawyer about their problems when they might not be able to afford the attorney in the end. It leads to a lot of back and forth communication. Clients just want to know prices. We used technology to cull the web and find prices for 30,000 attorneys and published that data. It was really hard to try and extrapolate what the dollar signs meant because it really could mean anything. Eventually, we organized that data so that users could see a visual histogram of pricing for attorneys in a certain region. You can see outliers and where attorneys tend to cluster in terms of median pricing. Now we only publish data on aggregated basis.
What's the most interesting thing you've discovered from this data?
We collaborated with researchers at the Brookings Institution to figure out which variables drive an attorney's fees. We submitted all pricing data and what we thought would be dependent and independent variables (i.e. law school, location, number of years as a practitioner, firm or solo practitioner). One day, the researcher called me and told me that there was a problem with the data. After lengthy analysis, he found that location determined 40% of the price, and experience determined 10% of the price. But there was no statistical significant for the other independent variables. However, the data wasn't wrong. Instead, the study ultimately concluded that 50% of the variation in attorney fee pricing is purely made up. So essentially, attorney fee pricing is bullshit. This study will be published in the American Journal of Economics later this year.
What's been your greatest challenge?
Our greatest challenge is probably the same challenge as every law startup out there--building a sustainable business. It's really hard. The revenue coming in has to be more than the capital flowing out. It's already hard to raise money and find funding; it's even harder to build a sustainable business. I've probably seen some ten other law startups go up and out of existence.
Any advice to budding legal entrepreneurs then?
Focus on building a business. Stop thinking about disrupting the industry. Theoretical and philosophical ponderings are nice, but they don't ultimately matter.
What's your goal for AttorneyFee?
We want to get into the business of law. We see hundreds of law firms buying marketing service in order to find new customers, but getting the customers to pay is as big a challenge as getting customers in the first place. We see a huge issue with cash flow in the legal practice. Sometimes customers don't have enough money for a retainer and attorneys find themselves need to take the case on credit. However, most law firms do not have lines of credit or collection departments. That's what we want to get into. We took our inspiration to innovations in capital happening in the medical field, and are gearing up this October to release our mobile platform that will front the money for clients to pay the attorney. We will then collect from the client over time. This injects law firms with liquidity. This requires a lot of financial expertise and capital. Moreover, the entire transaction is instantaneous. Cases will be approved or rejected in a matter of seconds. We believe that a client walking into a law firm to procure legal services is much like the customer who walks to a car dealership to buy a car. Once that customer walks off the lot, the possibility of them returning to buy the car is small. By allowing instantaneous approvals, we let lawyers close the transaction.
What are the ethical implications to this idea?
Attorneys do have ethical obligations to not file frivolous suits, but ethics don't really come into play here. This mostly revolved around the consumer's acknowledgement of the obligation to return the money.
What has been your relationship with consumers? Attorneys?
Consumers like us a lot, because they can't get the information we provide anywhere else. They also appreciate that it's free. Attorneys tend to fall in one of three camps: 1) the ones who see us as the apocalypse towards the commodification of their jobs; 2) the ones who love us. 10,000 attorneys return to AttorneyFee periodically to check trends in pricing and adjust their own to be more competitive; and 3) ambivalent. Some just don't care.
What's in store for the future of AttorneyFee?
We have a clear vision of our future. We're planning 10 new hires in the next days. We're increasing our bandwidth and investing lots of month in our growth over the next six months. We are preparing to do something very disruptive and novel in the legal industry.
Mootus: Attorney Collaboration and Reinventing Reputation
Today we feature Adam Ziegler, Co-Founder and CEO of Boston-based Mootus and the Boston Legal Innovation Meetup (more on that later). Mootus hosts a citation-based Q&A platform that facilitates the exchange of legal knowledge and expertise, and brings attorney reputation into the 21st century by helping lawyers build an online legal reputation.
Tell us about yourself:
Before law school, I spent two years as a paralegal and office manager in a solo practitioner's office in DC. After graduating from Michigan Law School in 2002, I clerked on the 6th Circuit and interned with the Appellate Staff of the Civil Division of the Department of Justice. Then, I spent a year at Covington and Burling in DC doing environmental insurance litigation and white collar defense work, and then spent 3 years at Goodwin Proctor in Boston doing large-scale commercial litigation and SEC investigations. I really wanted to be in the courtroom and get the experience of being a trial attorney, and I had no interest in becoming a litigation partner who had never tried a case. Since that opportunity wasn't available in a large firm, I left for a small boutique litigation firm named Donnelly, Conroy & Gelhaar. I loved my experience there, spent plenty of time on my feet in court, and become a partner there in early 2011.
And then what happened?
The firm, people and experience were all terrific, but I had an overriding frustration with the unavoidable fact that so much of my work (and that of others) was redundant and ultimately unnecessary. Like all lawyers, I was continually reinventing the wheel and spending an extraordinary amount of time defending against frivolous arguments. I became obsessed with finding a way to collaborate and share knowledge without betraying the core tenets of the legal profession. That frustration and obsession prompted me to pursue Mootus.
Was there any one experience that made the light bulb go off?
One of my favorite clients was a small, non-profit documentary film company that was sued by a big software company. It was a classic David versus Goliath case--the big company had a problem with what my client said on its website and sued for trademark infringement and defamation. My client ultimately prevailed, but during the litigation it made the decision to post the pleadings from the case online to bring some transparency to the dispute. This got a lot of attention. Lots of trademark experts analyzed the case and weighed-in online in favor of my client. This experience opened my eyes to the possibilities of open-source legal knowledge and crowdsourced legal analysis, and I became very focused on figuring out how to harness that kind of activity to help improve the quality and efficiency of legal work.
Mootus is both a marketplace and repository for legal knowledge. Users can pose concise legal queries, and others can respond by citing primary legal authority. It's not an open-ended Q&A platform; we only accept answers in the form of a citation (and an explanatory parenthetical). Once a response is posted, others can vote the response as “on point” or “off base.” The result is a rich thread of legal debate and conversation, as well as a compendium of citations relevant to a given legal issue. We’re providing a new way to put legal knowledge to work and to tap into the expertise and efforts of lawyers. We also make the content openly accessible on the web to give lawyers a better starting point so they don’t have to completely reinvent the wheel when researching a given issue.
How have you dealt with the ethical issues?
We care a great deal about legal ethics, and we’ve done a few key things to promote ethical behavior. First, we’re very explicit in our terms that if you are looking for legal advice, you should leave our site and go hire a lawyer instead (and tell them to use Mootus to reduce the hours spent on unnecessary research). We are not a lawyer lead generation site. Second, we’ve built the site to be interesting and useful mainly to lawyers. We welcome non-lawyers to view and even interact with the content on our site. It’s our view that lawyers should be more transparent, and the public should have more visibility into what lawyers and courts do. But the reality is that most non-lawyers don’t find legal citations or legal analysis very interesting. Third, all of the questions on our site are anonymous, and the answers are presumptively anonymous and private. So a lawyer can use the site without fearing that she will be publicly associated with her activity on the site unless and until she’s ready to take advantage of the reputational benefits of providing high quality responses.
One concern I've heard from lawyers not in the "legal startup field" is that the startups are trying to get lawyers to do things in ways that the tech community works, but not how the legal community works. How have you addressed this concern?
Mootus is built to be very similar to what lawyers already do. It’s simulated legal argument. Yes, it's online, yes it's open, but at end of the day, its just like writing a piece of a brief and adding a citation and parenthetical to support an argument. It’s just like finding ways to rebut an adversary’s arguments or to distinguish cases cited by the other side. Good law wins. Persuasive arguments attract support. The lawyers we talk to tell us its very natural because it fits their conception of how the law already works.
What has been your biggest challenge?
Our biggest challenge has been getting lawyers comfortable with the basic notion of being content creators online. The rest of the world is used to saying and doing things online, having an identity online, and liking and interacting with one another. Lawyers have been slow to adapt. Although that’s changing in a big way, for many lawyers online activity is still a little weird. It's still new behavior. Fundamentally, Mootus is trying to get lawyers to transition from being passive consumers of online information to interactive producers of information. That’s no small challenge, but we’re confident in our approach.
What's been your biggest success?
It’s too early for us to claim any success. But I’m proud that we've maintained our focus on what makes lawyers valuable and unique. It’s not always fashionable these days, but we are advocates for lawyers, especially good ones who are committed to delivering high quality services efficiently. We're not coming from outside the industry trying to make the case that lawyers are superfluous and easy to replace. We place great value in lawyers, and we want to help them develop better ways to deliver their services to more clients. In keeping with that philosophy, we try to highlight what's great about lawyers and the law--the notion of authority-based argument, legal hierarchy, and the rule of law, to name a few. I'm very happy that we’ve stayed true to that.
What is your great hope for Mootus?
In a perfect world, Mootus will become an integral part of the legal industry. In the process we’ll elevate the quality of legal work, eliminate waste, create new, profitable opportunities for lawyers to put their law degrees to work, and help lower the cost of providing legal services to those who need them. For lots of reasons, I think the legal industry is in the early stages of a fundamental transformation, and I believe Mootus can be a big part of that.
I've noticed that Mootus specifically targets students. Why is that?
Two reasons. First, generally speaking, new and aspiring lawyers are more comfortable with online activity, so they’re quicker to understand our vision for the future of legal work. Second, we're trying to make it possible for law students and new graduates to get some practice doing what lawyers do--engaging in legal argument and having the experience of rebutting what someone else says--at volume with high repetition. My view is that in law school, law students are taught how to do it, but they’re not given enough opportunity to practice it. When they graduate, it’s too late for “practice,” and instead they must develop this skill where it really matters, with the client’s interests and dollars on the line. Mootus allows students and grads to develop skills in a safer place where there is less pressure and mistakes can be learning opportunities rather than disasters. As they improve, they can use their online reputation (similar to a portfolio on Github) to market themselves to law firms and clients.
Two reasons. First, generally speaking, new and aspiring lawyers are more comfortable with online activity, so they’re quicker to understand our vision for the future of legal work. Second, we're trying to make it possible for law students and new graduates to get some practice doing what lawyers do--engaging in legal argument and having the experience of rebutting what someone else says--at volume with high repetition. My view is that in law school, law students are taught how to do it, but they’re not given enough opportunity to practice it. When they graduate, it’s too late for “practice,” and instead they must develop this skill where it really matters, with the client’s interests and dollars on the line. Mootus allows students and grads to develop skills in a safer place where there is less pressure and mistakes can be learning opportunities rather than disasters. As they improve, they can use their online reputation (similar to a portfolio on Github) to market themselves to law firms and clients.
For example, we give users a free profile to describe who they are and to give them stats on how they're doing on the site (i.e. how well answers are received, the number of questions they've answered, site ranking), as well as a portfolio of past activity. Profiles are private by default, but users can make them public when they’re ready to use them for marketing purposes. We believe this type of online legal reputation someday could be more informative and influential than law school grades and law school rankings. It’s our goal to empower new lawyers to take control of their legal reputation and to have the ability to improve that reputation over time based solely on the merit of self-directed activity, independent of exam performance, school pedigree and employment status.
Anything you want to pass on to other entrepreneurs?
I’m an unwavering advocate for legal startups, but I strongly believe in having real legal experience on the team to provide insight into product, customers and strategy. I’m not talking about anybody with a JD – I mean somebody who actually practiced law and advised a lot of real clients. It can take many different forms -- founder, employee, advisor, mentor, investor or whatever. I’ve seen companies without that perspective make some really stupid mistakes, and I think companies with a real first-hand understanding of the way the legal industry works will have the most success in changing it. In my view, it’s different from the typical startup perception that you can disrupt entirely from the outside. In the legal industry, you need deep domain expertise, understanding and depth to get it right. It's like medicine--it's difficult to fix without expertise and knowledge about where the problems and opportunities actually exist. We're not building consumer apps that tap into widespread needs and behaviors common to just about everyone. Instead, we’re delivering products and services to a specific group of highly educated professionals with unique obligations, interests, motivations and values. I welcome new lawyers, and anyone else, to the legal entrepreneurship field, but I strongly believe that to succeed your team should include someone who really knows the legal industry from the inside.
And by the way, I think the reverse is true too. For any lawyers or law students out there, don’t think for a second that you can build something that really matters without having professional technical expertise as a core part of your team. I’m fortunate to have a great technical expert, Jeff Schneller, as my co-founder, and without him Mootus would just be another idea rattling around in my head.
Anything you want to add?
Just that there is an immense amount of opportunity for innovation in the legal field. I think it’s fantastic that more and more startups (and investors) are pursuing the legal industry, and I hope it continues. Don’t get scared by the stereotype of the risk-averse, technophobic lawyer. Be informed about the important ethical constraints that exist in the legal world, but don’t give up on the possibility of doing something original within those constraints. If your first idea doesn’t pan out, stay at it and find something else. There are way more opportunities than there are people willing and able to take them.
Sunday, September 8, 2013
Gap Analysis: Criminal Law
The Guardian published a story this morning entitled "The wealthy 'make mistakes', the poor go to jail." Its the story about a former Wall Street banker who left his Wall Street job to start a photo project documenting the lives of addicts in the Hunts Point section of the Bronx, New York City's poorest neighborhood. While his Wall Street colleagues borrowed and lost others' money and walked away with $300,000 bonuses and government bailouts, a New York City prostitute finds herself going between the streets and jail for having sold her body for $50. The writer explains what he has learned from knowing both the Wall Street banker and the prostitute: "When you're wealthy you make mistakes. When you are poor you go to jail." He further explains:
There are two points to be made here: First, that there is need for systemic change in how the law treats different classes--whether that be more strictly enforcing the law against professionals, providing more wiggle room for the poor, or meeting the two classes halfway. Second, my guess is that the Wall Street bankers had the help of an army of very expensive attorneys fighting to help him create that interpretive wiggle room in the law, while the prostitute had little to no substantial legal assistance--at most, an overworked public defender.
I still haven't come across any legal startup in the field of criminal law. My guess is that its difficult to find a scaleable solution (since each situation is different), and because it's a scary field for the risk-averse lawyer to enter. After all, the Model Rules for Professional Conduct require that an attorney zealously advocate on behalf of their client. The bar of representation is higher than that for civil cases, making it unlikely that any legal entrepreneur would, for example, offer limited scope or virtual legal services in the field of criminal law. That essentially leaves these folks with the option of hiring expensive legal representation or settling with an overworked, underpaid public defender. (Learn more about the plight of pubic defenders here, here, and here.)
So if you're a legal entrepreneur out there searching for a problem to solve (as if there aren't enough already), this is a field ripe for change.
In the 1800s, Mark Twain joked that “the law is a system that protects everybody who can afford a good lawyer.” Two hundred years later, same story.
[...] it is
like comparing apples and oranges. That is the point though. We have built two
very different societies with two very different sets of values. Takeesha was
born into a world with limited opportunities, one where the black market has
filled the void. In her world transgressions are resolved via violence, not
lawyers. The law as applied to her is simple and stark, with little wiggle
room.
Mr
one-glove was born into a world with many options. The laws of his land are
open for interpretation, and with the right lawyer one can navigate in the vast
grey area and never do anything wrong. The rules are often written by and for
Mr one-glove and his friends.
There are two points to be made here: First, that there is need for systemic change in how the law treats different classes--whether that be more strictly enforcing the law against professionals, providing more wiggle room for the poor, or meeting the two classes halfway. Second, my guess is that the Wall Street bankers had the help of an army of very expensive attorneys fighting to help him create that interpretive wiggle room in the law, while the prostitute had little to no substantial legal assistance--at most, an overworked public defender.
I still haven't come across any legal startup in the field of criminal law. My guess is that its difficult to find a scaleable solution (since each situation is different), and because it's a scary field for the risk-averse lawyer to enter. After all, the Model Rules for Professional Conduct require that an attorney zealously advocate on behalf of their client. The bar of representation is higher than that for civil cases, making it unlikely that any legal entrepreneur would, for example, offer limited scope or virtual legal services in the field of criminal law. That essentially leaves these folks with the option of hiring expensive legal representation or settling with an overworked, underpaid public defender. (Learn more about the plight of pubic defenders here, here, and here.)
So if you're a legal entrepreneur out there searching for a problem to solve (as if there aren't enough already), this is a field ripe for change.
In the 1800s, Mark Twain joked that “the law is a system that protects everybody who can afford a good lawyer.” Two hundred years later, same story.
Saturday, September 7, 2013
Legal Tech for the Poor
Reposting this, as it looks to be an interesting event! (Access to Justice point!)
The original posting is here.
Online Resources and Innovative Technologies to Assist the Unrepresented
This workshop will look at online tools that are being used to assist those that have a legal problem and don't have an attorney representing them. They can be in court or in different forums, or they might be dealing with a private party before the case escalates. We will quickly review the building blocks of online self-help: online forms, web chat, and statewide websites and their tools and then focus on new and innovate tools that are coming into place that will be game changers. These include online triage, online self-help forums, SMS Texting for reminders in case, and innovative use of email and websites to serve persons protected by Federal laws in the context of veterans.
Date: Wednesday, September 11, 2013
Time: 1 pm ET / 12 pm CT / 11 am MT/ 10 PT
Time: 1 pm ET / 12 pm CT / 11 am MT/ 10 PT
Panelists:
- Gordon Shaw, Executive Director Massachusetts Justice Project
- Raquel Colon, Deputy Director Legal Services of Northern VA
- Kathleen Caldwell, Website Coordinator, Pine Tree Legal Assistance
Moderator:
- Claudia Johnson, Pro Bono Net Program Manager LawHelp Interactive
Webinar Details
Register: The training will be held via join.me, so no pre-registration is required. We’ve attached an iCalendar attachment to this email so this event can be easily added to your calendar.
Register: The training will be held via join.me, so no pre-registration is required. We’ve attached an iCalendar attachment to this email so this event can be easily added to your calendar.
Join the meeting:
https://join.me/NTAPtraining
Please enter your full name when prompted, followed by your organization information
(i.e. Jillian Theil, Pro Bono Net)
https://join.me/NTAPtraining
Please enter your full name when prompted, followed by your organization information
(i.e. Jillian Theil, Pro Bono Net)
Join the audio conference:
No matter how you join the conference, everyone will be on the same audio call.
No matter how you join the conference, everyone will be on the same audio call.
By phone:
Join the meeting, click on the phone icon and select "Join by phone." Dial the number and then the conference ID when prompted.
Join the meeting, click on the phone icon and select "Join by phone." Dial the number and then the conference ID when prompted.
By computer via internet:
Join the meeting, click the phone icon and select 'Join by internet'. Click "Connect."
Join the meeting, click the phone icon and select 'Join by internet'. Click "Connect."
For more information on how to use the join.me platform, please see this useful resource from LSNTAP.
To see the full schedule of upcoming LSNTAP trainings for the year, please visit http://lsntap.org/trainings. For questions about these trainings, please contact Jillian Theil of Pro Bono Net at jtheil@probono.net or (415) 400-8662, or Brian Rowe of Northwest Justice Project at brianr@nwjustice.org or (206) 395-6094 or through LSNTAP.org chat.
Monday, September 2, 2013
Introductions, or: Bringing to Law a Little More Order
This blog is meant to chronicle the rise of law-related startups and other innovative legal solutions that will afford people more access to justice. But first, a point of honesty-- I really don't know what's out there, and chances are, I'm guessing most people (and even lawyers) don't know either. When I first tried to start Lawcerna in March 2013, I thought I was bloody brilliant for coming up with the idea that law was a field that could or should be disrupted. Fast forward a couple of months, my list of "competitors" made me feel like I was the last person on Earth to have the light bulb go off.
Lawcerna, for now, is belly-up, but I wanted to provide a space for legal entrepreneurs to share their lessons and experiences with each other. After all, the larger we build this community and the more people we encourage to explore legal innovation, the higher the chances are that there will be someone or some people out there who "make it." The more who "make it," the better it is for consumers of legal services, ultimately. Plus, we'll convert those in the legal profession along the way to be more open to better, more efficient way to deliver legal services.
Why does legal innovation matter? A few reasons. The legal industry has priced itself into oblivion, and only in the financial reach of the rich and, sometimes, the destitute (though there is rapidly shrinking funding for non-profit legal services). Due to sky-high tuition rates, lawyers feel financially compelled to work for big law firms to pay their student debt. The ABA continues to sit on its hands when it comes to access to capital, deregulation, and deployment of technology in the legal sector. While every other sector is undergoing disruption, so much of the legal field remains antiquated and old-school. Change is probably also very welcome to lawyers themselves, as we surpass dentists as #1 in suicides. Probably not a great thing thing to brag about...But there is hope. A few brave souls are trying to change the way law is taught, understood, and practiced. Legal startups and virtual law firms seem to be springing up left and right. Most (like Lawcerna) seem to go under within a year, but many are still chugging along. Their contributions will hopefully create a kinder, gentler practice of law financially accessible to the middle class. It's a commendable effort, so this blog will attempt to capture their stories here. Suggestions are always welcome.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



